Small town news for a small town girl

I got my first paycheck from the Clovis Independent. They hired me the summer after high school, and I remember feeling both humbled and haughty (like all recent high school graduates–I was pretty darned important). I didn’t do very much as their news aide, and wrote only two articles I think, but I kept this summer work on my resume as long as I could. I always made room to describe my contribution to “The Bee Swatters,” the summer softball team: “Maintained positive attitude despite zero-win record.”

On this day

I can’t remember what the feature was called, but one of my favorite things to do was to find items for its 5-year, 10-year and I think 50-year “Remember when’s” or “On this day…” I’d go to the Clovis library branch and heave down these giant binded copies of the paper, and get lost flipping through small town history. At the time, I tired of the Clovis “way of life,” but I couldn’t help loving the stories behind the stories of city politics or high school champions. The ads were as fascinating as the news. The price of beef and cans of peas were often just a few cents.

Senior Stars

I also liked proofreading (and typing into the computer) the Senior Star features, where senior citizens narrated their lives with simple profound statements like: “I married my sweetheart at 17 and left Oklahoma,” “I worked there for 43 years,” and “after my husband died.” I’m a sucker for personal histories, and hidden behind my partition, I would shed tears reading them.

As a reader

In high school, I wondered why full-grown adults with all their faculties would bother with the piddly-lives of students. I saw reporters like Jenny McGill (recently laid-off from Coalinga’s shuttered paper) and Denny Boyles (now working for the Bee) taking serious interest in things like what my tennis coach Dick Ramage had to say about our upcoming match. Apparently, I thought, there was enough paper in the world to publish that trivia.

What I never appreciated at the time was how tremendously fact-checked and fair that public service was. It wasn’t out there to upend the political system, or dig through government records to get dirt. Its mission was to document the everyday folksy life of its residents. I read about the elderly man who walked everyday on Shaw and Temperance Ave. I read about the little kid who made friends with the janitor, after it was discovered that his dad was a custodian before he died. I read about my friends and the high school stars winning things like “All-star super student…of the Valley!” Did anyone else save these clippings from the Clovis Independent?

Back to the present

Before I get even more carried away– and believe me, I can– I ask myself: But, do I read it now? No. If its death wasn’t imminent, would I have noticed? Probably not. If I lived in Clovis, I might subscribe if it were cheap enough, but then again, not until I had kids in school. According to Ulrichs periodicals (which I accessed through a library) the Independent had a circulation of 5,000 paid subscriptions in 2007.

Last night, I told a few of my Clovis expatriate friends about the paper, “Who will write about entitled students and athletes?!” I typed, semi-seriously.

And they were all shocked, as anyone can be shocked on IM.

“What?”

“You’re kidding!”

“I was on their police blotter.” They wrote.

“Really?” responded one skeptically, followed by a long pause. “I didn’t see anything about it on their website.”

At any rate, what’s done is done. Good luck Patti, who I think is still the editor of the Clovis Independent. She may not remember, but she was my boss when I was there, and I admired her and her life. What’s next for newspeople? Who knows. Maybe it’s into the blogosphere for all of us. But on this day in history, this week? A small town girl once again shed tears over memories in the Clovis Independent.

South Valley bureau, Clovis Independent and Madera’s Sierra Star take hit for the rest of the company

Someone just punched me in the stomach.

I’m winded because The Fresno Bee is laying off 44 of its staff to keep pace with McClatchy’s directive to cut 10% of its workforce. But more personally, it’s because the Bee is concentrating that pain on the Clovis Independent, Madera paper, and the South Valley bureau (Visalia) where I worked for two-and-a-half years as a business reporter.

Those were the days

I was there at it’s zenith. Just a few years ago, at the height of the real estate advertising revenue, the Bee was pushing hard to conquer new territory in the South Valley. Visalia, bursting with new housing developments and served by the Times-Delta (known for overworked and inexperienced reporters) seemed like good pickings. At one time, I think we had almost as many journalists (13) working in the bureau as the Times-Delta did for its daily paper. The competition was fun and friendly. But the competition made everyone better.

Down to 3 journalists

In 2006, as the economy and advertising revenue slowed down, the bureau stopped filling positions from attrition. The bureau, as of today, is almost half that size: 4 reporters, two photographers, and one editor. In a few weeks it will be down to three. Two photographers and two undecided reporters will be laid off. Its editor is being transferred to Fresno.

I don’t have details, but I have also heard that The Clovis Independent–a fine, weekly publication that gave me my first job– will be completely shuttered by the end of June and that Sierra Star in the North Valley will go from twice a week to once a week starting the first week of July.

Why am I writing this? No, I’m not a vulture, hungry for a juicy scoop. I’m not that kind of journalist anymore. I’m writing this because this is information that in today’s media environment, is begging to be released. As librarian Meredith Farkas says, “Information wants to be free.” If I don’t write it, someone else will and should. This is news in today’s times. The Bee and McClatchy in general has been struggling to make a transition to online journalism. Although Fresno’s online community isn’t developed enough to have a dedicated blogger serving as a watchdog on traditional media, it’s only a matter of time before someone takes up that necessary role.

Another reason is to list, as an outsider now, my ideas on how I’d like to see the Fresno Bee evolve to serve my current needs as a news consumer. This list is short. I’m not a futurist, and I’m also hampered by my history. I think like an old-fashioned journalist. I encourage anyone who is reading this to also send ideas to the Fresno Bee on what they would like to see in its news outlet of the future. If the Fresno Bee is to survive, and believe me, it may not, they need to give us what we want and need.

All these suggestions could have been made in 2007, but here are some ideas inspired by what I’ve experienced as a consumer trying to READ the Bee, and also heavily influenced by USC’s Online Journalism Review, which for some reason is ALSO shutting down today…(Is nothing sacred in online media?)

Ten ways I’d like to see the Fresno Bee improve online:

1. The entire website needs to change. It makes no sense to me, I see national stories on the front page, when I have already seen those played out everywhere else and on my news feeds. It’s a major turn-off period. Even when I figure it out, I can’t bear to navigate past the first page.

2. More in-depth packages like the Saroyan package. Unlike the birth of Christ, multimedia packages should not arrive just once a year. But also, write more about less, like McClatchy’s DC bureau recent work on Guantanamo. Leave the minutiae for bloggers.

3. More user-generated content. The Bee should have gotten the hint from one-man-band Adrian Rodriguez at Lateupdate.com on how possible it is to be a hub for Fresno-made YouTube, blogs, etc.

4. Create deep, informative pages where I can see past coverage of what a reporter has written and what beat he or she covers. Reporters such as EJ Schultz, the Sacramento correspondant, should have his own page where I can see at a glance the status of 5-10 different bills pertaining to the Valley. And a running list of stories he has written about them. Or for Mike Oz fans, how about a page dedicated to all things Mike, music and more Mike.

5. A better pipeline of citizen bloggers. Online Journalism Review does a good job of explaining how to encourage them, but the Bee should anoint someone to be a head blogger/volunteer coordinator inspiring, motivating, and rewarding quality posts. There are SO MANY smart, inspired professionals already blogging: scientists, policy wonks, food lovers. Wouldn’t it be neat to read blogs from homeless people in Fresno, or teenagers, or farmers? I’d like to see all these blogs collated at Fresnobee.com.

6. More transparancy. The Bee should be frank with its readers about its challenges. Why, for instance, is it taking so long to redesign the site. And why is it so hard to find the “news” beehive–the blog for most of the news reporters? If there’s a good reason, let it be known, otherwise, please make it easy to find. I LOOK for it, and I still can’t find it sometimes.

7. This is also an idea I’ve seen on OJR, but I’d like to see “evergreen” stories updated and maintained by reporters or copyeditors, maybe on a wiki. Wouldn’t it be nice to be able to see the most recent update of the Fresno mayoral race without gerrymandering a google search for “fresno mayoral AND race site:fresnobee.com” and “fresno mayoral race site:fresnobeehive.com”?

8. WRITE FOR THE WEB!!! There aren’t even any hyperlinks in the online version of the news stories. Add the recommended reading that served as the foundation for your reporting.

9. Make the archives free. Sure you can find it at your local library, but it’d be nice to be able to search without the hassle. It’s also silly to let all those in-depth articles wither away because it’s past the two week searching period. How can anyone link to them from their blogs, knowing that they’ll be inaccessible in a few weeks?

10. Make more mistakes. Take more risks online! Would readership drop any more?

So I’ve just blown this out of my a$#, really I’m just shaken up about my poor colleagues–both victims and survivors– that I could think of little else to do. I really loved working with my colleagues and professionals at the Bee.

What ideas do any of you have? I’d really like to see the Fresno Bee around for years and years. Writing this blog reminds me of how time consuming it must be to produce one story and to fact check (which is pretty much absent from blogging, including this one). At the same time, I find it shocking how out of touch its online presence is. I hadn’t visited in two years and when I returned, it seemed like I had never left. In the meantime, I am encouraged by the aggressive and relevent work of bloggers like Mike Lukens at San Joaquin Valleyfornia. That’s a citizen journalist that makes me hopeful for the future.

Web surfers probably know what it’s like to find a great website, only to discover that the information on the San Joaquin Valley is scant or suspiciously presented.

Did a robot do this? Did someone in Montana write this “local” piece?

Well we at Valley Notebook want to feature national websites that DO make sense for the San Joaquin Valley, or at least provide worthwhile content.

Fortune 535, a project released this week from the Sunlight Foundation, provides the public with an easy way to search congress’ personal net worth.

Some data we found about three local congressmen (Devin, George and Jim) according to Fortune 535:

  • Jim Costa blows his three club-mates out of the water with an avg. net worth of $3.5 million in 2006.
  • Devin Nunes‘ 2006 avg. net worth is nothing to sneeze at at $91,002, but his net worth actually dropped after joining congress. (Hm… did his marriage have something to do with it??)

Don’t believe us? Search for yourself.

And you can also do the fun work of analyzing their research methods, the data, and even the actual financial documents themselves. The most recent PDFs of the financial documents are available. Whoever works for Devin has beautiful handwriting.

Sunlight Foundation admits themselves that the data is inscrutable and spotty. According to the submitted documents, Nancy Pelosi could either be wealthy or bankrupt, they say. They’re advocating for stricter guidelines on disclosure.

Fortune 535 also compares congress members’ wealth to the average American family’s.

(Congress wins.)

Editors’ note:

This is part of an on-going series of posts on the Valley’s creative movement and its counterpart the central valley brain drain.

If you are part of the brain drain and would like to participate, answer the questions you see below and send them to valley.notes AT gmail DOT com. Please give us ideas on how we can improve this series.

Brain Drain Chronicles: Garth, 26

Name (first name OK): Garth

Age: 26

Where did you attend high school? Clovis High School

What is your educational background?

I graduated from California State University, Fresno in Spring of 2005 with my B.S. in Criminology and an option of Victimology.
What is your current occupation? Supervising Counselor at a group home in Boston for children who have been abused and neglected.

Where and how long did you live in the central valley?

I lived in Clovis, Ca for 18 years.
Where do you live now? I live in Boston, Ma

Why do you (don’t you) live in the central San Joaquin Valley?


I don’t live in the central valley anymore, because I just got tired of the lifestyle in that area. Many other parts of Ca are beautiful, but for me right now, I like living in a city with less sprawl and more forward thinking as far as city development.

What are the secondary reasons?

I am enjoying exploring a part of the country that is much different from where I grew up. The changes in weather as well as the differences in people’s attitudes on the east coast are fun.

What are the top 5-10 adjectives that come to mind when you think of the central valley?

hot, dry, sprawling, conservative, grid-like.

How often do you visit? (Editor’s Note: New question!)

Usually about twice a year.

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what changes/acts of God would need to occur in order for you to move there?

I would need to have no other choice but to return. So for instance, to help my direct family members because of sickness or death. Or if for some reason I absolutely needed their support and lost all my money or had some illness which required me to be taken care of.

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what price would make it worthwhile?

The central valley already has a pretty low cost of living. Especially comparing it to my current residence in Boston. With that said, I don’t think I would move back despite how cheap it is. I value what I have in Boston too much to move back.

Editors’ note:

This is part of an on-going series of posts on the Valley’s creative movement and its counterpart the central valley brain drain.

If you are part of the brain drain and would like to participate, answer the questions you see below and send them to valley.notes AT gmail DOT com. Please give us ideas on how we can improve this series.

Brain Drain Chronicles: Arthur, 26

Name: Arthur

Age: 26

Where did you attend high school? Clovis High School

What is your educational background?

Attended Stanford University as an undergrad, was majoring in English Literature, but I didn’t complete the degree. Maybe I’ll finish it some other time in the distant future.

What is your current occupation?

Administrative Assistant at Space Systems Loral (they design satellites).

Where and how long did you live in the central valley?

I was born in Fresno and pretty much lived there until I left for college. I briefly moved back for a year or so before leaving yet again.

Where do you live now?

San Mateo, CA
Why do you (don’t you) live in the central San Joaquin Valley?

After moving to the bay area, Fresno became a much smaller space to me. When I visit home these days, time feels like it’s slowed down and I get irritated by the monotonousness. I prefer to immerse myself within a more diverse environment, which I feel the bay area offers at the moment.

What are the secondary reasons?

Aside from my family, nobody I am close to stayed behind. Most of my Fresno/Clovis friends have moved on themselves. I feel like I have a much more defined social network where I currently live.

Also, I noticed some people mentioned the heat. The heat during the summer is absolutely unbearable for me now that I’ve experienced less scorching summers.

What are the top 5-10 adjectives that come to mind when you think of the central valley?

Negatives: slow, synthetic, lacking. Positives: fertile (referring to the actual countryside), comfortable, homely.

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what changes/acts of God would need to occur in order for you to move there?

I think maybe with age I’d consider returning to Fresno. Well, maybe I’d just own property that I could visit at my convenience.

I guess also, if any of my immediate family ever required assistance, I’d return.

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what price would make it worthwhile?

Maybe if I was financially set up that I could travel outside of Fresno with ease and frequency.

Feel free to add any comments.

Fresno will always be home. And I genuinely feel satisfied with my upbringing there. I hope to see it flourish culturally. There’s a lot of potential that just needs to be fully realized.

Editors’ note:

This is part of an on-going series of posts on the Valley’s creative movement and its counterpart the central valley brain drain. We’re tracking down former Valley residents (with a preference on educated “creative class”-types) and finding out what they’re doing, why they don’t live in the Valley, and what it would take for them to move back.

If you are part of the brain drain and would like to participate, answer the questions you see below and send them to valley.notes AT gmail DOT com. We’re working on tracking down a more diverse array of participants (i.e. not our classmates) but alas, you have to start somewhere!

Please give us ideas on how we can improve this series. We admit that this is sub-scientific, but we’re finding the answers enlightening nonetheless.

Brain Drain Chronicles: Madeline, 27

Name: Madeline

Age: 27

Where did you attend high school? Clovis High School

What is your educational background?

B.A. Literature in English with a minor in Vocal
Music and Spanish Literature from U. C. San Diego.
Master’s in Library and Information Science (MLIS)
from San Jose State University.

What is your current occupation?

Youth Services Librarian II, San Jose Public Library

Where and how long did you live in the central valley?

First grade–12th grade (1986-1999). I consider Clovis
my hometown.

Where do you live now?

Los Gatos, CA (Silicon Valley).
Why do you (don’t you) live in the central San Joaquin Valley?

I always felt judged in Clovis… for not being Christian enough or conservative enough or middle America enough….

What are the secondary reasons?
No major university, lacking diversity (or least a supportive environment to encourage it), car culture, chain store culture, suburban sprawl, poor air quality.

Actually, the heat never bothered me…
What are the top 5-10 adjectives that come to mind when you think of the central valley?
Close-minded, flat, religious, uniform, hot

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what changes/acts of God would need to occur in order for you to move there?

The fact that God factors into this sentence is so
telling…

I think the entire culture of the Valley would need to change before I’d feel comfortable there. If it suddenly filled with progressive people, I’d make an easy transition back.

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what price would make it worthwhile?

A higher paying job couldn’t lure me back. The Bay Area pays me well enough, and my current high cost-of-living seems worth it considering the amount of beauty and culture I regularly experience here.

Feel free to add any comments.

I do love to visit the Valley. I feel like I’ll always have a special bond with the friends I made in Clovis, especially those who went away for college, experienced something new, and returned to experience Clovis in a new light.

Editors’ note:

This is part of an on-going series of posts on the Valley’s creative movement and its counterpart the central valley brain drain. We’re tracking down former Valley residents (with a preference on educated “creative class”-types) and finding out what they’re doing, why they don’t live in the Valley, and what it would take for them to move back.

If you are part of the brain drain and would like to participate, answer the questions you see below and send them to valley.notes at gmail.com. We know using our network alone will have an inherent bias.

Please give us ideas on how we can improve this series.

Brain Drain Chronicles: Jay, 26

Name: Jay

Age: 26

Where did you attend high school?
Clovis High

What is your educational background?

B.A. Northwestern, Economics

What is your current occupation?

Policy Researcher. I work at a think tank where I do economic and demographic research on poverty and welfare issues.

Where and how long did you live in the central valley?

Fresno. 18 years, 1982-2000.

Where do you live now?

San Francisco

Why do you (don’t you) live in the central San Joaquin Valley?
I left for college. Moved to DC for a job. Then moved to San Francisco for my current job.

What are the secondary reasons?
For an ethnically diverse county of about a million residents, Fresno still manages to be uninteresting. It’s a combination of suburban sprawl, terrible air quality, high unemployment, high concentrations of poverty (#1 in the US), conservative myopia, struggling schools and an obdurate religiosity (I should note that this combination makes it incredibly interesting for sociological/economic/demographic research, but not an incredibly interesting place to live). I don’t think I would be able to advise a 20-something college graduate to live there without feeling a considerable amount of guilt. Seeing the latest box office hit at Edwards passes as a cultural outing. Finding food takes a tremendous amount of effort and driving if you don’t want to eat at a chain restaurant. Only the Tower District seems to show a glimmer of progress and hope.

To be fair, there are a few very brave and intelligent people that are capable of creating interesting and meaningful lives in Fresno. However, I have neither motivation nor the creative capacity to do the same. Give me the beauty of urban living with its infinite cultural options, great food, great bars, public transit systems and progressive people with an eclectic array of interests.

What are the top 5-10 adjectives that come to mind when you think of the central valley?

Conservative, ag-based, slow, rural/suburban, characterless, religious, air pollution-y, hot (temperature)

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what change/acts of God would need to occur for you to move there?
An act of God indeed. Just about everything.

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what price would make it worthwhile?

I’m guessing you’re referring to the cost-of-living. As an unmarried 26 year old without children, cost-of-living isn’t my greatest concern. Since there are no employment options in the valley that interest me, there’s really no price that would get me to move back. I can almost understand moving to the valley if you have a family and your line of work is more ubiquitous or somehow related to agriculture. However, if I had a child, education would be a greater consideration than the affordability of housing. There were a small handful of administrators and teachers in Clovis that were able to inspire and educate me enough to get into a good college, which was no small feat. But looking back at my overall experience, the school system encouraged rote memorization over intellectual curiosity and fostered very little tolerance and compassion in its students.

Feel free to add any comments.

Only 14% of people over 25 years old in the valley (this includes Sacramento Valley) have at least a bachelor’s degree compared to 28% in the rest of California. Even the Inland Empire, which is boasting an upward trend in educational attainment, has a higher proportion of college-educated residents (19%). The brain drain in the valley is severe.

Editors’ note:

This is part of an on-going series of posts on the Valley’s creative movement and its counterpart the central valley brain drain. We’re tracking down former Valley residents (with a preference on educated “creative class”-types) and finding out what they’re doing, why they don’t live in the Valley, and what it would take for them to move back.

If you are part of the brain drain and would like to participate, answer the questions you see below and send them to valley.notes at gmail.com. We know using our network alone will have an inherent bias.

Please give us ideas on how we can improve this series.

Brain Drain Chronicles: Justin, 27

Name (First name or shortened name OK): Justin

Age: 27

Where did you attend high school?

Buchanan High

What is your educational background?

BA, High Honors, Swarthmore College (Music Major, English Literature Minor)

MM, University of Nevada-Las Vegas (Music Composition/Theory)

DMA, University of Texas at Austin — Beginning in Fall 2008 (Music Composition)

What is your current occupation?

Assistant Director of a Huntington Learning Center
Where and how long did you live in the central valley?

I was born in Fresno in 1980, but moved away before I was 1. We moved back to Fresno in 1990 and then to Clovis in 1992. I left for college in 1998 and my family was no longer there as of July 2000.

Where do you live now?

Henderson, Nevada (soon to be Austin, Texas)

Why do you (don’t you) live in the central San Joaquin Valley?

When I left, I was eager to get away from the social, political, and ideological identity that the valley held in my eyes. I wanted to go to a “good school”, and in the sort of elitism to which young people are often predisposed, that meant I had to go somewhere else. It was valuable because it gave me a broader worldview and a set of different experiences, but it was a bit wrongheaded.

What are the secondary reasons?

There’s no reason left for me to return. Without family attachments and without real job prospects in my chosen field, Fresno and Clovis are novelties — places where I can go and see that the city and town I knew aren’t there anymore.

What are the top 5-10 adjectives that come to mind when you think of the central valley?

Changed

Boomerang (Not an adjective, but I feel like people struggle to stay away once they’ve been there for a long time)

Hot

Agrarian

Close-ish to “Home”

Reactionary

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what changes/acts of God would need to occur in order for you to move there?

There would have to be an extraordinary opportunity as a composer or professor, or I would have to be seized by a horrible fit of nostalgia and my wife and daughter would have to agree to the terms of fog and heat.

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what price would make it worthwhile?

There would have to be sufficient pay to allow a ridiculous standard of living, replete with waterfront home, measurable land, and a fully-equipped music studio.

Feel free to add any comments.

I misjudged the Valley when I left. In my youthful posturing, I convinced myself that it was nothing but a breeding ground for early breeding, mental mediocrity, and provincial political ideas, and that was not an altogether accurate assessment. However, for the foreseeable future, there’s no conceivable reason or justification for us (my wife, Emma, and our daughter, Zoë) to move back. Interesting side note about Minkler — I discovered it while aimlessly driving out toward Reedley for an Honor Band rehearsal, and was amused (I suppose) by the statistical happenstance that would lead Minkler (then population 34) to attain the highest murder rate in the country if one person snapped over some sort of cooking mishap.

Editors’ note:

This is part of an on-going series of posts on the Valley’s creative movement and its counterpart the central valley brain drain. We’re tracking down former Valley residents (with a preference on educated “creative class”-types) and finding out what they’re doing, why they don’t live in the Valley, and what it would take for them to move back.

If you are part of the brain drain and would like to participate, answer the questions you see below and send them to valley.notes@gmail.com. We know using our network alone will have an inherent bias.

Please give us ideas on how we can improve this series.

Brain Drain Chronicles: Sarah, 27

Name (first name OK):
Sarah

Age:
27

Where did you attend high school?

Clovis High, Class of 99

What is your educational background?

BS Electrical Engineering, Cal Poly, San Luis Obispo


What is your current occupation?

I integrate satellite payloads for Northrop Grumman, as an RF Test Engineer

Where and how long did you live in the central valley?

I lived in Clovis for 19 years.

Where do you live now?

I live in El Segundo, CA

Why do you (don’t you) live in the central San Joaquin Valley?

I got recruited by Northrop Grumman in Redondo Beach 5 months before I graduated from Cal Poly.

What are the secondary reasons?

My chosen specialty of aerospace engineering isn’t readily offered by the Central Valley companies.

What are the top 5-10 adjectives that come to mind when you think of the central valley?

Home,
Hot,
Reasonable,
Foggy


If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what changes/acts of God would need to occur in order for you to move there?

Job-loss,
Starting a family

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what price would make it worthwhile?

If a major aerospace company started satellite production in the valley.
Standard of living remains stable.

The Creative Movement

We’re happy to introduce an ongoing series of posts on the Valley’s creative movement and its counterpart the Central Valley Brain Drain. We’ll be tracking down former Valley residents (with a preference on educated “creative class”-types) and finding out what they’re doing, why they don’t live in the Valley, and what would it take for them to move back.

It’s our first foray into this type of content, so expect it to evolve as the posts continue.

Note: Our concept for this humble site is to provide content on issues facing the central San Joaquin Valley. Since we are not currently located in the Valley (we left too!), a natural theme to pursue included the brain drain phenomena, and the work that Creative Fresno and others are doing to combat this. Expect a posting with more interviews and background material.

Note: This was sent and returned as an e-mail survey. If you have suggestions on how to improve the questions/process, please let us know. We’re blogging novices.

Brain Drain Chronicles: Robyn, 25

Name : Robyn

Age: 25

Where did you attend high school? Clovis High School

What is your educational background? B.A. Columbia University 2004, J.D. NYU 2008

What is your current occupation? Law Student; Public Defender


Where and how long did you live in the central valley?
Clovis 1986-2000

Where do you live now? New York City

Why do you (don’t you) live in the central San Joaquin Valley? I moved to go to college and then stayed away for law school.

What are the secondary reasons? The food is better, the air is better, there is more diversity, the bars are better, the cultural options are more plentiful, there is more to do, my job is here, most of my close friends live here now (or at least not in the Valley). I’m never bored.

What are the top 5-10 adjectives that come to mind when you think of the central valley? Dusty, hot, Mormon (adj.), agricultural, driving-based, truck-y, conservative, and Tsing Tao (adj.).

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what changes/acts of God would need to occur in order for you to move there? New York City would need to be located in the Valley.

If you do not currently live in the central San Joaquin Valley, what price would make it worthwhile? If I ever moved back to the Valley, it wouldn’t be because of cost of living. I’m acutely aware that the place I live now is ridiculously expensive, but after seven years, it has never tempted me to move back to the Valley.

Feel free to add any comments. The Valley is where I grew up, New York is my home.